| Chicago Steel Youngstown Phantoms | Youngstown Phantoms | 3:2 | | | | 29.09.2024 |
| Madison Capitols Youngstown Phantoms | Youngstown Phantoms | 2:3 PEN. | | | | 28.09.2024 |
| Sioux City Youngstown Phantoms | Youngstown Phantoms | 2:1 | | | | 19.09.2024 |
| Youngstown Phantoms Tri-City Storm | Tri-City Storm | 4:3 ET | | | | 19.09.2024 |